Written by Aglaia Berlutti · Translated by Marianna Breytman
Snowden, charged with espionage and property theft by the United States government, is currently on Russian territory, where he is attempting to avoid extradition to American soil.
Maduro’s offer comes at a complicated diplomatic moment: UNASUR (Union of South American Nations [2]) demanded an apology from Europe due to the incident [3] suffered by Evo Morales, during which various countries closed their airspace to the Bolivian leader based on suspicions that he was transporting Snowden.
In events leading up to the military parade that celebrated 202 years since the signing of the Venezuelan declaration of independence on Friday, July 5, President Maduro stated [4] [es] that, “As leader of the State and Government of the Bolivarian Republic of Venezuela, I have decided to offer humanitarian asylum to the American young man, Snowden.”
Maduro explained that Venezuela is offering the measure to Snowden to “protect him from the persecution that has been unleashed from the most powerful empire in the world against a young man who has told the truth”.
A day later, the Venezuelan president confirmed his intention via Twitter (@NicolasMaduro [5]) [es]:
@NicolasMaduro [6]: Ratifico el espíritu humanitario de conceder el asilo al joven estadounidense Snowden para protegerlo de la persecución mundial del imperio.
@NicolasMaduro [6]: I confirm the humanitarian spirit of granting asylum to Snowden, the young American, to protect him from the empire’s global persecution.
President Maduro had mentioned the possibility of welcoming Snowden on various occasions, but this is the first time he has done it openly and directly.
Despite the controversy, the United States government declined to make comments regarding the Venezuelan president’s offer. According to Reuters [7] [es], the White house has not released an opinion on the issue and referred questions to the country’s Department of Justice.
Nevertheless, on Sunday, July 7, a group of U.S. Congress members established their position on Snowden’s possible political asylum, stating that: “Whatever country offers asylum to Edward Snowden, who leaked data from the National Security Agency’s (NSA) surveillance program, will set itself against the United States.”
The announcement [8] [es] appears to be a direct response to statements made by Venezuela and Bolivia to grant the humanitarian measure to the former U.S. contractor.
Nonetheless, despite the Venezuelan president’s offer, on Monday, July 7, Edward Snowden requested political asylum from Nicaragua through a letter [9], information that was confirmed directly by the government of the Central American country.
“I, Edward Snowden, citizen of the United States, am writing to request asylum from the Republic of Nicaragua due to the risk of being persecuted by the Government and its agents,” he explains in the letter, dated June 30, 2013. In it, Snowden also explains the consequences that he can suffer after revealing the United States’ secret electronic surveillance program, which he fears could result in the Espionage Act of 1917 [10]being applied against him. If found guilty under this U.S. law, Snowden could be sentenced to life in prison.
It is worth highlighting that the request for asylum – or the offer that President Maduro made – is duly stipulated in Venezuelan legislation in the Organic Law on Refugees or Refugees and Asylum-seekers (published in Official Gazette No. 37,296 dated 03 October 2001).
The debate on social networks
The offer of asylum to the former NSA contractor on behalf of President Maduro has sparked a heated debate in Venezuela between those who support the government’s position with respect to asylum and those who criticize it by considering it unnecessary and merely political. Above all, the offer seemed to intensify the political confrontation between both countries and it is reflected as such on social networks.
On the forum “Aporrea,” which tends to be pro-government, Maduro’s decision is supported almost unanimously. Ecuadorian President Rafael Correa’s position is also praised [es]:
rararoadrunner (Foro Aporrea) [12]: ¿Será necesario que UNASUR envie una escuadrilla, compuesta por un avión de cada país, para acompañar a Edward Snowden de Moscú a su país? A ver: lo que vemos ahora es que usted encarna la gloria al bravo pueblo, un ejemplo para tod@s! ¡Vivan los Estados independientes de América, el sueño del Libertador, Simón Bolívar!
rararoadrunner (Foro Aporrea) [12]: Will it be necessary for UNASUR to send a squadron, composed of a plane in every country, to accompany Edward Snowden from Moscow to their country? Let’s see: what we see now is that you embody glory to the brave people, an example for everyone! Long live the independent States of America, the dream of the Liberator Simón Bolívar!
Deuteros (Foro Aporrea) [13]: Ecuador está mostrando una actitud bastante valiente y digna en este asunto; Rafael Correa es un gran ejemplo de líder. Esperemos que Rusia asuma una postura más frontal respecto a Snowden.”
Deuteros (Foro Aporrea) [13]: Ecuador is showing quite a brave and dignified attitude towards this issue; Rafael Correa is a great example of a leader. We hope that Russia assume a more head-on position with respect to Snowden.”
Even so, pro-government political analyst Nicmer Evans criticizes the governmental offer on his blog [14] [es]:
Lo más interesante del caso es que el ser de la CIA o haberlo sido ahora es tan “chic” que nuestro país no podía quedarse atrás en tener su propio ex agente delator, y hemos corrido a ofrecer asilo a el exCia más cotizado del mercado: Snowden, que como una estrella del pop está siendo debatido por muchos países en cuanto a quien ofrece el mejor asilo en solidaridad con quien hasta hace poco era el responsable de que todos estuviésemos pinchados por los gringos a través de Prism, y hoy es la panacea de ejemplo revolucionario mundial.
The most interesting thing about the case is that the being of the CIA or having been it is now so “chic” that our country cannot remain behind in having its own former informing agent, and we have run to offer asylum to the most valued ex-CIA member in the market: Snowden, like a pop star, is being thrashed around by many countries in terms of who will offer the best asylum in solidarity with someone who, until recently, was responsible for everyone being bugged by the gringos through Prism, and today is the formula for an example of a global revolutionary.
There are also citizens who believe the offer of political asylum is a sign of good will.
Francys Caridad (@francyscaridad [15]) [es], for example, celebrates the possibility of Snowden arriving in Venezeula:
@francyscaridad [15]: #SnowdenBienvenidoAVenezuela [16] bienvenido a venezuela snowden! #snowden [17] #venezuela [18] #asilo [19] #asilopolitico [20]
@francyscaridad [15]: #SnowdenBienvenidoAVenezuela [16] [#SnowdenWelcomeToVenezuela] welcome to venezuela snowden! #snowden [17] #venezuela [18] #asilo [19] #asilopolitico [20] [#asylum #politicalasylum]
Héctor Abad (@hectorabadf) [es] comments on the U.S. position with respect to Edward Snowden’s legal situation:
@hectorabadf [21]: Snowden es ahora un apátrida perseguido y sin derecho a asilo, por decir la verdad de que todos podemos ser espiados por la NSA.
@hectorabadf [21]: Snowden is now a persecuted, stateless individual without the right to asylum for telling the truth about how we can all be spied on by the NSA.
Mariela Azocar (@MarielaMartha [22]) [es] also supports President Nicolás Maduro’s decision to offer humanitarian asylum to the former U.S. contractor:
@MarielaMartha [23]: @NicolasMaduro [5] Buen día mi querido presidente si lo apoyo en darle asilo al joven Snowden. Venezuela será su casa…
@MarielaMartha [23]: @NicolasMaduro [5] Good day my dear president if you support the young Snowden in giving him asylum. Venezuela will be his home…
Marianny Barroso (@MARIANNYBARROSO [24]) [es] considers the decision of the Venezuelan state to be convenient in offering political asylum to Edward Snowden and supports it publicly:
@MARIANNYBARROSO [25] Snowden hoy es amenaza de un Gobierno q a hecho mucho daño a nivel mundial!! por eso APOYO el ASILO en Venezuela! patria de BOLIVAR y CHAVEZ
@MARIANNYBARROSO [25] Snowden today is a threat of a Government that has done a lot of harm on a global scale!! that is why I SUPPORT ASYLUM in Venezuela! Homeland of BOLIVAR and CHAVEZ
Twitter users also debated how the asylum could affect the already quite deteriorated political and diplomatic relations between Venezuela and the U.S., in addition to the case involving the former contractor’s legal situation.
In Josefina Ruggiero’s (@ruggieroj [26]) [es] opinion, the words of the President of the DUMA (the lower house of the Russian Federal Assembly) summarize part of what are the current political relations between Venezuela and the United States:
@ruggieroj [27]: Presidente de la Duma: la relacion de Vzla con EEUU es tan mala que el caso del joven Snowden no la empeorara. Esta clarito #asiloSnowden [28]
@ruggieroj [27]: President of DUMA: Venezuela’s relationship with the U.S. is so bad that Snowden’s case will not worsen it. It is clear #asiloSnowden [28] [#Snowdenasylum]
Still, for Luis Carlos Díaz (@LuisCarlos [29]) [es], journalist and Global Voices [30] collaborator, the concern is more about citizen rights.
@LuisCarlos [31]: Hay demasiado foco en Snowden y muy poco en el espionaje de los estados y la privacidad de los ciudadanos
@LuisCarlos [31]: There is too much focus on Snowden and very little on state espionage and the privacy of citizens
Venezuelans even attempt to analyze the political problem from an almost humorous perspective, as is the case of Alejandro Barrios (@alepicture [32]) [es]:
@alepicture: [33] el rechazo de maduro es tan grande que le ofrece #Asilo [34] a #Snowden [17] en #Venezuela [18] y el lo ignora…
@alepicture: [33] The rejection of Maduro is so great that he is offering #Asilo [34][#Asylum] to #Snowden [17] in #Venezuela [18] and he is ignoring it…
Perhaps Twitter user @WATH23 [35] [es] summarized Venezuelan expectations about Snowden’s response to the Venezuelan offer:
@WATH23 [36]: Edward Snowden lleva días en el Trending Topic Venezolano. Hoy llega al primer puesto con su negación al asilo político en Venezuela.
@WATH23 [36]: Edward Snowden has been a Trending Topic in Venezuela for days. Today he reaches first place with his rejection of political asylum in Venezuela.
At the time of writing this post, Nicaragua has not yet ruled on the Snowden’s request for asylum. At the same time, President of Venezuela, Nicolás Maduro, stated that Venezuela received a formal request for asylum [37] from the former American contractor.
Article printed from Global Voices: http://globalvoicesonline.org
URL to article: http://globalvoicesonline.org/2013/07/09/venezuelas-president-offers-asylum-to-edward-snowden-and-controversy-erupts